Real Estate Strate
Author: Muhammad Itani — Founder & Strategic Director, Veraluxe
Case Study No. 01 | Return on Investment (ROI)
The Hidden Cost of an Empty Apartment
How a Lebanese investor compares annual leasing, furnished rentals, and a renovation strategy using risk-adjusted returns. Hypothetical educational case — all figures modeled
1. Context and investment objective
An investor owns a vacant 120 m² apartment in Aley, Mount Lebanon. The property is structurally sound, has two bedrooms, and requires modest refurbishment before it can be marketed competitively.
The investor is considering three strategies: renting the apartment unfurnished under an annual lease, furnishing it for short-term stays, or undertaking a more substantial renovation to attract a higher-paying annual tenant.
The investor’s objective is not simply to maximize advertised rent. It is to determine which strategy produces the strongest sustainable return after vacancy, operating expenses, additional capital expenditure, and uncertainty.
The central question is:
Should the investor pursue the highest potential rental income or the most dependable risk-adjusted return?
This case is entirely hypothetical. The property, rents, costs, occupancy rates, and investment outcomes are modeled assumptions, not verified Lebanese market observations. All amounts are expressed in USD.
2. Initial assumptions
The investor already owns the apartment. To compare the alternatives economically, the analysis uses a hypothetical current property value of $140,000 rather than the owner’s historical purchase price.
Modeled current property value
$140,000
Apartment size
120 m²
Analysis horizon
One stabilized year
Financing
No debt assumed. The model excludes property appreciation, income tax, financing costs, eventual selling expenses, and terminal resale value. These exclusions are identical across all alternatives.
3. Three investment alternatives
| Assumption | A: Basic annual lease | B: Furnished short-term | C: Renovated annual lease |
| Additional capital | $5,000 | $22,000 | $35,000 |
| Advertised rent | $750/month | $95/night | $1,050/month |
| Occupancy | 11 months/year | 45% of nights | 11.5 months/year |
| Annual operating costs | $1,500 | $5,800 | $2,000 |
| Total capital employed | $145,000 | $162,000 | $175,000 |
Annual operating costs include modeled maintenance, owner-paid utilities or services, management, and other recurring expenses as applicable. They exclude the initial refurbishment or furnishing investment, which is included in capital employed.
For the short-term alternative, 45% occupancy is assumed to represent 164.25 occupied nights in a 365-day year. Fractional nights are used only for expected-value modeling.
4. The strategic dilemma
Alternative B offers the highest possible gross revenue when the apartment is occupied. Its nightly rate appears attractive compared with conventional annual rent.
However, short-term accommodation requires more intensive management, cleaning, guest turnover, utilities, marketing, and periodic replacement of furnishings. Revenue is also sensitive to seasonal demand and booking cancellations.
Alternative C may attract a more stable tenant and reduce day-to-day management demands. Nevertheless, the investor must commit substantially more capital before generating rental income.
Alternative A is less ambitious but requires minimal additional investment and offers relatively predictable cash flow.
The strategist must compare income, capital efficiency, operating complexity, and downside exposure, rather than select an option solely on its advertised rent.
. Step-by-step ROI calculations
The principal formula is:
[ \ Net rental yield} =\ {\ {Annual NOI}} {\ {Total capital employed}} \*100 \]
Net operating income (NOI) is calculated as gross collected rental income minus recurring operating expenses, before financing and income taxes.
Alternative A — Basic annual lease
Annual rental income:
\ [ \$750\times11=\$8,250 \]
Annual NOI:
\ [ \$8,250-\$1,500=\$6,750 \]
Total capital employed:
\ [ \$140,000+\$5,000=\$145,000 \]
Net rental yield:
\ [ \frac {\$6,750} {\$145,000} \times100=\boxed {4.66\%} \]
Alternative B — Furnished short-term rental
Expected occupied nights:
\ [ 365\times45\%=164.25 \]
Expected annual gross income:
\ [ 164.25\times\$95=\$15,603.75 \]
Annual NOI:
\ [ \$15,603.75-\$5,800=\$9,803.75 \]
Total capital employed:
\[ \$140,000+\$22,000=\$162,000 \]
Net rental yield:
\ [ \frac {\$9,803.75} {\$162,000} \times100=\boxed {6.05\%} \]
Alternative C — Renovated annual lease
Annual rental income:
\ [ \$1,050\times11.5=\$12,075 \]
Annual NOI:
\ [ \$12,075-\$2,000=\$10,075 \]
Total capital employed:
\ [ \$140,000+\$35,000=\$175,000 \]
Net rental yield: \ [ \frac {\$10,075} {\$175,000} \times100=\boxed {5.76\%} \]
6. Comparative financial results
Modeled annual net rental yields
Basic lease · Short – term C · Renovated lease
Illustrative, unleveraged, pre-tax yields on total capital employed.
| Measure | A | B | C |
| Gross annual income | $8,250 | $15,604 | $12,075 |
| Annual NOI | $6,750 | $9,804 | $10,075 |
| Net yield | 4.66% | 6.05% | 5.76% |
Alternative B leads in percentage return on total capital, while Alternative C produces the highest annual NOI. These are different financial objectives.
7. Sensitivity analysis: The occupancy risk
The critical uncertainty is the occupancy rate for Alternative B.
Assuming the nightly rate remains $95 and operating expenses remain fixed at $5,800, the following outcomes emerge:
| Occupancy | Annual NOI | Net yield |
| 30% | $4,602.50 | 2.84% |
| 40% | $8,070.00 | 4.98% |
| 45% | $9,803.75 | 6.05% |
| 50% | $11,537.50 | 7.12% |
| 60% | $15,005.00 | 9.26% |
Simplified sensitivity: operating costs held constant; actual variable costs may rise with occupancy.
To match Alternative C’s annual NOI, the furnished apartment would need:
To match Alternative C’s 5.76% yield on capital employed, it would need approximately 43.62% occupancy.
The difference matters: matching a competitor’s dollar income is not the same as matching its percentage return when capital requirements differ.
The simplified model assumes fixed operating expenses. In practice, cleaning, utilities, platform commissions, and maintenance can increase with occupancy, so a detailed operating budget would be required before investment.
8. Strategic decision and explanation
The strategist selects Alternative A as the immediate, lower-commitment strategy, while treating Alternative B as a conditional future opportunity.
This choice does not maximize the modeled percentage return. It preserves flexibility and avoids committing $22,000 to furnishing before evidence of achievable nightly rates and occupancy is available.
The recommended sequence is to lease the property conventionally, monitor comparable short-term accommodation performance, and reassess the market before the next leasing decision.
If credible evidence subsequently supports sustained occupancy above the modeled threshold, the investor may consider furnishing the apartment after accounting for transition costs and lost rent.
Alternative C remains appropriate for an investor prioritizing higher absolute annual NOI and a conventional leasing structure, provided the renovation budget and achievable rent can be independently validated.
The strategic lesson is that a lower initial yield may be rational when it preserves capital and reduces exposure to uncertain assumptions.
9. Modeled outcome — not an actual transaction
Under the selected Alternative A, the first stabilized year is projected to produce:
Annual gross rent
$8,250
Annual NOI
$6,750
Total capital employed
$145,000
Net rental yield
4.66%
These figures represent a hypothetical stabilized year, not a completed lease, guaranteed return, or forecast of actual Aley market performance.
10. Practical lessons for the real estate strategist
- Distinguish gross rent from net operating income. An attractive advertised rate can conceal substantial expenses.
- Use a consistent investment denominator. Include property value and additional capital when comparing alternative uses of an existing asset.
- Measure absolute income and percentage return separately. The option generating the highest NOI may not offer the highest yield.
- Stress-test the most uncertain assumption. For short-term rentals, occupancy and nightly pricing are often decisive.
- Recognize the value of flexibility. Preserving capital can be strategically preferable to pursuing a higher modeled return.
- Do not mistake a spreadsheet outcome for a market fact. Verify rents, occupancy, expenses, title, permitted use, and applicable tax treatment before implementation.
Strategic principle
The real estate strategist does not ask only, “Which property produces the highest return?” The stronger question is, “Which investment strategy offers the most defensible return for the capital, uncertainty, and obligations involved?”
